Reforming Treatment of Business Start-up Expenditures

Today, once a business starts carrying on business (when it is no longer getting ready, but is instead ready to serve customers), it can start amortizing its start-up expenditures as defined under IRC Section 195 over 15 years. If the total is $55,000 or less, up to $5,000 can be expensed immediately and this amount phases down as the aggregate expenditures range from $50,001 to $55,000.

S. 5204, Tax Relief for New Businesses Act, would increase the expensing amount from $5,000 to $50,000 and the phaseout point to $150,000. The bill sponsors note that the average small business spends about $40,000 to get their businesses from getting ready to carrying on.

Those with over these amounts today or per S. 5204, are amortizing expenses over 15 years. Meanwhile, we allow use of the cash method of accounting by most businesses, and have Section 179 expensing of over $1 million. Why not just allow the small business to expense up to the Section 179 amount along with other eligible section 179 property? This sounds like simpler and would truly help small businesses. That is why amortize something over 15 years when Section 179 expensing is over $1 million?

This proposal is in a list of proposals from several years back from the AICPA Tax Division on modernizing the tax law for small businesses. I hope that upcoming tax reform will not just extend expiring or expired TCJA items but also take a look at reforms that would help businesses and make sense given other provisions in the law.

I've offered additional tax reforms to help small businesses in this blog. One of my favorites (beyond what is in the AICPA paper which I'm pleased to say I was able to assemble with other volunteers and staff when I was chairing the AICPA Tax Executive Committee), is allowing co-owners of a new business to elect to be a Qualified Joint Venture something which today is only available to spouses (where both file identical Schedule Cs). This would be very helpful for a start-up run by two or more people because while they are getting started, they don't have to deal with setting up an LLC or filing a partnership return - which is a lot of work when unfortunately, they might not survive. After a few years, they would be required to shift to a partnership or C or S corporation.

I'm sure many people have ideas to truly help simplify tax rules for small businesses. 

What do you think?